When Less is more and more is less in brief motivational interventions: Characteristics of intervention content and their associations with drinking outcomes

Anne E. Ray, Su Young Kim, Helene R. White, Mary E. Larimer, Eun-Young Mun, Nickeisha Clarke, Yang Jiao, David C. Atkins, David Huh

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

27 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Brief motivational interventions (BMIs) that aim to reduce alcohol use and related problems have been widely implemented in college settings. BMIs share common principles, but vary in specific content. Thus far, the variation in content has not been thoroughly understood in relation to intervention outcomes. The present study addressed this gap by examining variation in breadth of BMI content (i.e., total number of components covered), the extent to which content was personalized to participants, and the interaction between breadth and personalization in relation to treatment outcomes. Data (N = 6,047 participants across 31 separate BMI conditions) came from an integrative data analysis (IDA) study featuring individual-level data from a broad sample of 24 BMI studies of college students. Participants were assessed at baseline and at least 1 follow-up point, conducted up to 12 months postbaseline. Structural equation modeling revealed a significant interaction effect between breadth and personalization of BMI content on alcohol use and related problems at the long-term follow-up (6-12 months) but not at the short-term follow-up (1-3 months). Results indicated that "more is better" for reducing both alcohol use and related problems when BMIs were highly personalized to participants. For less personalized BMIs, coverage of more components was associated with increases in both alcohol use and problems. Findings point to the importance of strategically designing BMIs to maximize their impact on drinking outcomes in college students.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1026-1040
Number of pages15
JournalPsychology of Addictive Behaviors
Volume28
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - 1 Jan 2014

Fingerprint

Drinking
Alcohols
Students

Keywords

  • Brief motivational interventions
  • College students
  • Drinking outcomes
  • Intervention content

Cite this

Ray, Anne E. ; Kim, Su Young ; White, Helene R. ; Larimer, Mary E. ; Mun, Eun-Young ; Clarke, Nickeisha ; Jiao, Yang ; Atkins, David C. ; Huh, David. / When Less is more and more is less in brief motivational interventions : Characteristics of intervention content and their associations with drinking outcomes. In: Psychology of Addictive Behaviors. 2014 ; Vol. 28, No. 4. pp. 1026-1040.
@article{41cc35e1e62449a29fd5a162e21198d9,
title = "When Less is more and more is less in brief motivational interventions: Characteristics of intervention content and their associations with drinking outcomes",
abstract = "Brief motivational interventions (BMIs) that aim to reduce alcohol use and related problems have been widely implemented in college settings. BMIs share common principles, but vary in specific content. Thus far, the variation in content has not been thoroughly understood in relation to intervention outcomes. The present study addressed this gap by examining variation in breadth of BMI content (i.e., total number of components covered), the extent to which content was personalized to participants, and the interaction between breadth and personalization in relation to treatment outcomes. Data (N = 6,047 participants across 31 separate BMI conditions) came from an integrative data analysis (IDA) study featuring individual-level data from a broad sample of 24 BMI studies of college students. Participants were assessed at baseline and at least 1 follow-up point, conducted up to 12 months postbaseline. Structural equation modeling revealed a significant interaction effect between breadth and personalization of BMI content on alcohol use and related problems at the long-term follow-up (6-12 months) but not at the short-term follow-up (1-3 months). Results indicated that {"}more is better{"} for reducing both alcohol use and related problems when BMIs were highly personalized to participants. For less personalized BMIs, coverage of more components was associated with increases in both alcohol use and problems. Findings point to the importance of strategically designing BMIs to maximize their impact on drinking outcomes in college students.",
keywords = "Brief motivational interventions, College students, Drinking outcomes, Intervention content",
author = "Ray, {Anne E.} and Kim, {Su Young} and White, {Helene R.} and Larimer, {Mary E.} and Eun-Young Mun and Nickeisha Clarke and Yang Jiao and Atkins, {David C.} and David Huh",
year = "2014",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1037/a0036593",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "1026--1040",
journal = "Psychology of Addictive Behaviors",
issn = "0893-164X",
publisher = "Educational Publishing Foundation",
number = "4",

}

When Less is more and more is less in brief motivational interventions : Characteristics of intervention content and their associations with drinking outcomes. / Ray, Anne E.; Kim, Su Young; White, Helene R.; Larimer, Mary E.; Mun, Eun-Young; Clarke, Nickeisha; Jiao, Yang; Atkins, David C.; Huh, David.

In: Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, Vol. 28, No. 4, 01.01.2014, p. 1026-1040.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - When Less is more and more is less in brief motivational interventions

T2 - Characteristics of intervention content and their associations with drinking outcomes

AU - Ray, Anne E.

AU - Kim, Su Young

AU - White, Helene R.

AU - Larimer, Mary E.

AU - Mun, Eun-Young

AU - Clarke, Nickeisha

AU - Jiao, Yang

AU - Atkins, David C.

AU - Huh, David

PY - 2014/1/1

Y1 - 2014/1/1

N2 - Brief motivational interventions (BMIs) that aim to reduce alcohol use and related problems have been widely implemented in college settings. BMIs share common principles, but vary in specific content. Thus far, the variation in content has not been thoroughly understood in relation to intervention outcomes. The present study addressed this gap by examining variation in breadth of BMI content (i.e., total number of components covered), the extent to which content was personalized to participants, and the interaction between breadth and personalization in relation to treatment outcomes. Data (N = 6,047 participants across 31 separate BMI conditions) came from an integrative data analysis (IDA) study featuring individual-level data from a broad sample of 24 BMI studies of college students. Participants were assessed at baseline and at least 1 follow-up point, conducted up to 12 months postbaseline. Structural equation modeling revealed a significant interaction effect between breadth and personalization of BMI content on alcohol use and related problems at the long-term follow-up (6-12 months) but not at the short-term follow-up (1-3 months). Results indicated that "more is better" for reducing both alcohol use and related problems when BMIs were highly personalized to participants. For less personalized BMIs, coverage of more components was associated with increases in both alcohol use and problems. Findings point to the importance of strategically designing BMIs to maximize their impact on drinking outcomes in college students.

AB - Brief motivational interventions (BMIs) that aim to reduce alcohol use and related problems have been widely implemented in college settings. BMIs share common principles, but vary in specific content. Thus far, the variation in content has not been thoroughly understood in relation to intervention outcomes. The present study addressed this gap by examining variation in breadth of BMI content (i.e., total number of components covered), the extent to which content was personalized to participants, and the interaction between breadth and personalization in relation to treatment outcomes. Data (N = 6,047 participants across 31 separate BMI conditions) came from an integrative data analysis (IDA) study featuring individual-level data from a broad sample of 24 BMI studies of college students. Participants were assessed at baseline and at least 1 follow-up point, conducted up to 12 months postbaseline. Structural equation modeling revealed a significant interaction effect between breadth and personalization of BMI content on alcohol use and related problems at the long-term follow-up (6-12 months) but not at the short-term follow-up (1-3 months). Results indicated that "more is better" for reducing both alcohol use and related problems when BMIs were highly personalized to participants. For less personalized BMIs, coverage of more components was associated with increases in both alcohol use and problems. Findings point to the importance of strategically designing BMIs to maximize their impact on drinking outcomes in college students.

KW - Brief motivational interventions

KW - College students

KW - Drinking outcomes

KW - Intervention content

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84925791255&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1037/a0036593

DO - 10.1037/a0036593

M3 - Article

C2 - 24841183

AN - SCOPUS:84925791255

VL - 28

SP - 1026

EP - 1040

JO - Psychology of Addictive Behaviors

JF - Psychology of Addictive Behaviors

SN - 0893-164X

IS - 4

ER -