How the Brain May Have Shaped Muscle Anatomy and Physiology: A Preliminary Study

Magdalena N. Muchlinski, Holden W. Hemingway, Juan Pastor, Kailey M. Omstead, Anne M. Burrows

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Skeletal muscle fibers are often used to evaluate functional differences in locomotion. However, because there are energetic differences among muscle fiber cells, muscle fiber composition could be used to address evolutionary questions about energetics. Skeletal muscle is composed of two main types of fibers: Type I and II. The difference between the two can be reduced to how these muscle cells use oxygen and glucose. Type I fibers convert glucose to ATP using oxygen, while Type II fibers rely primarily on anaerobic metabolic processes. The expensive tissue hypothesis (ETH) proposes that the energetic demands imposed on the body by the brain result in a reduction in other expensive tissues (e.g., gastrointestinal tract). The original ETH dismisses the energetic demands of skeletal muscle, despite skeletal muscle being (1) an expensive tissue when active and (2) in direct competition for glucose with the brain. Based on these observations we hypothesize that larger brained primates will have relatively less muscle mass and a decrease in Type I fibers. As part of a larger study to test this hypothesis, we present data from 10 species of primates. We collected body mass, muscle mass, and biopsied four muscles from each specimen for histological procedures. We collected endocranial volumes from the literature. Using immunohistochemistry, a muscle fiber composition profile was created for each species sampled. Results show that larger brained primates have less muscle and fewer Type I fibers than primates with smaller brains. Results clarify the relationship between muscle mass and brain mass and illustrate how muscle mass could be used to address energetic questions. Anat Rec, 301:528–537, 2018.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)528-537
Number of pages10
JournalAnatomical Record
Volume301
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 2018

Fingerprint

anatomy
physiology
brain
Anatomy
muscle
Muscles
muscles
Brain
Primates
muscle fibers
skeletal muscle
Skeletal Muscle
glucose
energetics
Glucose
primate
Muscle Cells
oxygen
fiber cells
Slow-Twitch Muscle Fibers

Keywords

  • Type I muscle fibers
  • energetics
  • expensive tissue hypothesis
  • primate evolution

Cite this

Muchlinski, Magdalena N. ; Hemingway, Holden W. ; Pastor, Juan ; Omstead, Kailey M. ; Burrows, Anne M. / How the Brain May Have Shaped Muscle Anatomy and Physiology : A Preliminary Study. In: Anatomical Record. 2018 ; Vol. 301, No. 3. pp. 528-537.
@article{076cfda58f064521bdf1909084e72065,
title = "How the Brain May Have Shaped Muscle Anatomy and Physiology: A Preliminary Study",
abstract = "Skeletal muscle fibers are often used to evaluate functional differences in locomotion. However, because there are energetic differences among muscle fiber cells, muscle fiber composition could be used to address evolutionary questions about energetics. Skeletal muscle is composed of two main types of fibers: Type I and II. The difference between the two can be reduced to how these muscle cells use oxygen and glucose. Type I fibers convert glucose to ATP using oxygen, while Type II fibers rely primarily on anaerobic metabolic processes. The expensive tissue hypothesis (ETH) proposes that the energetic demands imposed on the body by the brain result in a reduction in other expensive tissues (e.g., gastrointestinal tract). The original ETH dismisses the energetic demands of skeletal muscle, despite skeletal muscle being (1) an expensive tissue when active and (2) in direct competition for glucose with the brain. Based on these observations we hypothesize that larger brained primates will have relatively less muscle mass and a decrease in Type I fibers. As part of a larger study to test this hypothesis, we present data from 10 species of primates. We collected body mass, muscle mass, and biopsied four muscles from each specimen for histological procedures. We collected endocranial volumes from the literature. Using immunohistochemistry, a muscle fiber composition profile was created for each species sampled. Results show that larger brained primates have less muscle and fewer Type I fibers than primates with smaller brains. Results clarify the relationship between muscle mass and brain mass and illustrate how muscle mass could be used to address energetic questions. Anat Rec, 301:528–537, 2018.",
keywords = "Type I muscle fibers, energetics, expensive tissue hypothesis, primate evolution",
author = "Muchlinski, {Magdalena N.} and Hemingway, {Holden W.} and Juan Pastor and Omstead, {Kailey M.} and Burrows, {Anne M.}",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1002/ar.23746",
language = "English",
volume = "301",
pages = "528--537",
journal = "Anatomical Record",
issn = "1932-8486",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",
number = "3",

}

Muchlinski, MN, Hemingway, HW, Pastor, J, Omstead, KM & Burrows, AM 2018, 'How the Brain May Have Shaped Muscle Anatomy and Physiology: A Preliminary Study', Anatomical Record, vol. 301, no. 3, pp. 528-537. https://doi.org/10.1002/ar.23746

How the Brain May Have Shaped Muscle Anatomy and Physiology : A Preliminary Study. / Muchlinski, Magdalena N.; Hemingway, Holden W.; Pastor, Juan; Omstead, Kailey M.; Burrows, Anne M.

In: Anatomical Record, Vol. 301, No. 3, 03.2018, p. 528-537.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - How the Brain May Have Shaped Muscle Anatomy and Physiology

T2 - A Preliminary Study

AU - Muchlinski, Magdalena N.

AU - Hemingway, Holden W.

AU - Pastor, Juan

AU - Omstead, Kailey M.

AU - Burrows, Anne M.

PY - 2018/3

Y1 - 2018/3

N2 - Skeletal muscle fibers are often used to evaluate functional differences in locomotion. However, because there are energetic differences among muscle fiber cells, muscle fiber composition could be used to address evolutionary questions about energetics. Skeletal muscle is composed of two main types of fibers: Type I and II. The difference between the two can be reduced to how these muscle cells use oxygen and glucose. Type I fibers convert glucose to ATP using oxygen, while Type II fibers rely primarily on anaerobic metabolic processes. The expensive tissue hypothesis (ETH) proposes that the energetic demands imposed on the body by the brain result in a reduction in other expensive tissues (e.g., gastrointestinal tract). The original ETH dismisses the energetic demands of skeletal muscle, despite skeletal muscle being (1) an expensive tissue when active and (2) in direct competition for glucose with the brain. Based on these observations we hypothesize that larger brained primates will have relatively less muscle mass and a decrease in Type I fibers. As part of a larger study to test this hypothesis, we present data from 10 species of primates. We collected body mass, muscle mass, and biopsied four muscles from each specimen for histological procedures. We collected endocranial volumes from the literature. Using immunohistochemistry, a muscle fiber composition profile was created for each species sampled. Results show that larger brained primates have less muscle and fewer Type I fibers than primates with smaller brains. Results clarify the relationship between muscle mass and brain mass and illustrate how muscle mass could be used to address energetic questions. Anat Rec, 301:528–537, 2018.

AB - Skeletal muscle fibers are often used to evaluate functional differences in locomotion. However, because there are energetic differences among muscle fiber cells, muscle fiber composition could be used to address evolutionary questions about energetics. Skeletal muscle is composed of two main types of fibers: Type I and II. The difference between the two can be reduced to how these muscle cells use oxygen and glucose. Type I fibers convert glucose to ATP using oxygen, while Type II fibers rely primarily on anaerobic metabolic processes. The expensive tissue hypothesis (ETH) proposes that the energetic demands imposed on the body by the brain result in a reduction in other expensive tissues (e.g., gastrointestinal tract). The original ETH dismisses the energetic demands of skeletal muscle, despite skeletal muscle being (1) an expensive tissue when active and (2) in direct competition for glucose with the brain. Based on these observations we hypothesize that larger brained primates will have relatively less muscle mass and a decrease in Type I fibers. As part of a larger study to test this hypothesis, we present data from 10 species of primates. We collected body mass, muscle mass, and biopsied four muscles from each specimen for histological procedures. We collected endocranial volumes from the literature. Using immunohistochemistry, a muscle fiber composition profile was created for each species sampled. Results show that larger brained primates have less muscle and fewer Type I fibers than primates with smaller brains. Results clarify the relationship between muscle mass and brain mass and illustrate how muscle mass could be used to address energetic questions. Anat Rec, 301:528–537, 2018.

KW - Type I muscle fibers

KW - energetics

KW - expensive tissue hypothesis

KW - primate evolution

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85041846268&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/ar.23746

DO - 10.1002/ar.23746

M3 - Article

C2 - 29418115

AN - SCOPUS:85041846268

VL - 301

SP - 528

EP - 537

JO - Anatomical Record

JF - Anatomical Record

SN - 1932-8486

IS - 3

ER -