Assessing a traditional case-based application exercise and a student question creation exercise on student performance and perceptions

Amulya Vanguri Tatachar, Carol Kominski

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Background and purpose To compare the impact of a traditional case-based application exercise with a student question creation exercise on a) student exam performance, b) student perceptions of enjoyment, competence, understanding, effort, interest in continuing participation, and interest in the subject. Educational activity and setting Subjects were 84 second-year pharmacy students in a pharmacotherapy course. The research focus was active learning involving the topic of chronic kidney disease-mineral bone disorder. Student teams were randomly assigned to either case-based or student question creation exercises using PeerWise. Student performance was assessed by a pre- and posttest and on block and final exams. After completion, an online survey assessed student perceptions of both exercises. Findings Statistically significant differences were revealed in favor of the student question creation group on enjoyment and interest in the subject matter. No statistically differences were found between the traditional case-based group and the student question creation group on gain score from pre-test to posttest. The student question creation group performed slightly better than the case-based application group on two of the five questions on the block exam but none of these differences reached statistical significance. Discussion and conclusions Students randomly assigned to groups that created and reviewed questions exhibited slightly improved summative exam performance and reported significantly more positive perceptions than students engaging in a more traditional case-based learning activity. Student question creation has demonstrated potential as a useful learning activity. Despite inherent difficulties in designing studies involving educational research in a controlled environment, students who have submitted, created, rated, and answered peers’ questions have overall performed well.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)689-697
Number of pages9
JournalCurrents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning
Volume9
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - 1 Jul 2017

Fingerprint

Exercise
Students
Learning
Pharmacy Students
Chronic Kidney Disease-Mineral and Bone Disorder
Controlled Environment
Drug therapy
Problem-Based Learning
Research
Mental Competency
Minerals
Bone
Education
Drug Therapy

Keywords

  • Active learning
  • Student perceptions
  • Student performance
  • Student question creation

Cite this

@article{5eac5612fb9a48df84290d7fbbda9e9b,
title = "Assessing a traditional case-based application exercise and a student question creation exercise on student performance and perceptions",
abstract = "Background and purpose To compare the impact of a traditional case-based application exercise with a student question creation exercise on a) student exam performance, b) student perceptions of enjoyment, competence, understanding, effort, interest in continuing participation, and interest in the subject. Educational activity and setting Subjects were 84 second-year pharmacy students in a pharmacotherapy course. The research focus was active learning involving the topic of chronic kidney disease-mineral bone disorder. Student teams were randomly assigned to either case-based or student question creation exercises using PeerWise. Student performance was assessed by a pre- and posttest and on block and final exams. After completion, an online survey assessed student perceptions of both exercises. Findings Statistically significant differences were revealed in favor of the student question creation group on enjoyment and interest in the subject matter. No statistically differences were found between the traditional case-based group and the student question creation group on gain score from pre-test to posttest. The student question creation group performed slightly better than the case-based application group on two of the five questions on the block exam but none of these differences reached statistical significance. Discussion and conclusions Students randomly assigned to groups that created and reviewed questions exhibited slightly improved summative exam performance and reported significantly more positive perceptions than students engaging in a more traditional case-based learning activity. Student question creation has demonstrated potential as a useful learning activity. Despite inherent difficulties in designing studies involving educational research in a controlled environment, students who have submitted, created, rated, and answered peers’ questions have overall performed well.",
keywords = "Active learning, Student perceptions, Student performance, Student question creation",
author = "Tatachar, {Amulya Vanguri} and Carol Kominski",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.cptl.2017.03.007",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "689--697",
journal = "Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning",
issn = "1877-1297",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "4",

}

Assessing a traditional case-based application exercise and a student question creation exercise on student performance and perceptions. / Tatachar, Amulya Vanguri; Kominski, Carol.

In: Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning, Vol. 9, No. 4, 01.07.2017, p. 689-697.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Assessing a traditional case-based application exercise and a student question creation exercise on student performance and perceptions

AU - Tatachar, Amulya Vanguri

AU - Kominski, Carol

PY - 2017/7/1

Y1 - 2017/7/1

N2 - Background and purpose To compare the impact of a traditional case-based application exercise with a student question creation exercise on a) student exam performance, b) student perceptions of enjoyment, competence, understanding, effort, interest in continuing participation, and interest in the subject. Educational activity and setting Subjects were 84 second-year pharmacy students in a pharmacotherapy course. The research focus was active learning involving the topic of chronic kidney disease-mineral bone disorder. Student teams were randomly assigned to either case-based or student question creation exercises using PeerWise. Student performance was assessed by a pre- and posttest and on block and final exams. After completion, an online survey assessed student perceptions of both exercises. Findings Statistically significant differences were revealed in favor of the student question creation group on enjoyment and interest in the subject matter. No statistically differences were found between the traditional case-based group and the student question creation group on gain score from pre-test to posttest. The student question creation group performed slightly better than the case-based application group on two of the five questions on the block exam but none of these differences reached statistical significance. Discussion and conclusions Students randomly assigned to groups that created and reviewed questions exhibited slightly improved summative exam performance and reported significantly more positive perceptions than students engaging in a more traditional case-based learning activity. Student question creation has demonstrated potential as a useful learning activity. Despite inherent difficulties in designing studies involving educational research in a controlled environment, students who have submitted, created, rated, and answered peers’ questions have overall performed well.

AB - Background and purpose To compare the impact of a traditional case-based application exercise with a student question creation exercise on a) student exam performance, b) student perceptions of enjoyment, competence, understanding, effort, interest in continuing participation, and interest in the subject. Educational activity and setting Subjects were 84 second-year pharmacy students in a pharmacotherapy course. The research focus was active learning involving the topic of chronic kidney disease-mineral bone disorder. Student teams were randomly assigned to either case-based or student question creation exercises using PeerWise. Student performance was assessed by a pre- and posttest and on block and final exams. After completion, an online survey assessed student perceptions of both exercises. Findings Statistically significant differences were revealed in favor of the student question creation group on enjoyment and interest in the subject matter. No statistically differences were found between the traditional case-based group and the student question creation group on gain score from pre-test to posttest. The student question creation group performed slightly better than the case-based application group on two of the five questions on the block exam but none of these differences reached statistical significance. Discussion and conclusions Students randomly assigned to groups that created and reviewed questions exhibited slightly improved summative exam performance and reported significantly more positive perceptions than students engaging in a more traditional case-based learning activity. Student question creation has demonstrated potential as a useful learning activity. Despite inherent difficulties in designing studies involving educational research in a controlled environment, students who have submitted, created, rated, and answered peers’ questions have overall performed well.

KW - Active learning

KW - Student perceptions

KW - Student performance

KW - Student question creation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85019995275&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.cptl.2017.03.007

DO - 10.1016/j.cptl.2017.03.007

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - 689

EP - 697

JO - Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning

JF - Currents in Pharmacy Teaching and Learning

SN - 1877-1297

IS - 4

ER -